Charlie, do youthink my grading system is wrong? I do use a numerical system, though I do also describe defects that can't be seen in my super-large-and-clear-photos. I also have descriptions of my numerical system just below my grade estimate.. In my opinion, the large pic says more than any grading #
Rich, I don't think that any grading system is "wrong". I just think it insufficient to be the only source of information. Most dealers are not touting their grading system as the 'be all to end all' like Sean. If you use grading as a way to assist buyers make an informed decision in addition to descriptions and images, then grading can have a place; but more simply as just a toggling mechanism.
"Well in general I am not interested in anything less than a 7 unless it's rare..." "Show me everything 'Good to Very Good' or 7 and above.."
What cracks me up about numbers is: What is the amount of significance between say a '6' and a '7'... Sometimes a poster that looks like a '9' is a '6' because a corner is missing... So what about the 'worrier of condition' is not so worried about a 1/4" piece of the corner missing that he can cover with matting when framed? So now he toggled away that '9'...
Buyers use several different packages of information to make a decision and grading is just not that big an influence in my book. If there is a great description then you are no longer worried about what the grade means... It would be as simple as to say "new, used, well used, you don't want this one" just so you can toggle... Same as 'pin holes', 'edge fraying', 'small tears', 'surface loss', 'paper loss', 'creases', 'fading', 'writing', etc...
But to claim that a 'number grade' is where it is at, just illustrates that some would rather force a grading system down your throat simply because it makes listing posters easier.
To me the information package priority would be:
Title
Descriptors to Toggle (let's say I don't want any faded colors - done! without grade)
Grade to Toggle (Let's say generally I don't want any <4's or 'Fair' or worse - done!)
Actual Detailed Description of Flaws
Image to Confirm
Bid/Buy
Result less controversy on condition and reduced returns...