All Poster Forum
Common Poster Subjects => Authentication => Topic started by: yllum on June 28, 2015, 05:50:27 AM
-
Greeting to all fellow collectors, i am new here. Looking forward to learning from all seasoned collectors out there :)
I recently just bought my first Japanese original poster, b1 size of lupin castle of cagliostro 1979.
May I know if there is fake b1 for that title? It is not as popular compared to the other miyazaki title.so I assume there is no fake.
It measure around 28.5" x 40.5" and it has a eirin mark. The Eirin mark is clear, however the dates on the eirin mark are blur. .it that normal? Or this poster maybe a fake? I have attached picture of the eirin mark for your reference.
i found another original copy of this poster online from a very reputable seller, that seller send me a photo of the eirin mark for the one he is selling and it has the same blurred numbers.
Thank you for taking time out to read my msg, I appreciate any help given.
(http://i61.tinypic.com/hts3yh.jpg)
-
Greeting to all fellow collectors, i am new here. Looking forward to learning from all seasoned collectors out there :)
I recently just bought my first Japanese original poster, b1 size of lupin castle of cagliostro 1979.
May I know if there is fake b1 for that title? It is not as popular compared to the other miyazaki title.so I assume there is no fake.
It measure around 28.5" x 40.5" and it has a eirin mark. The Eirin mark is clear, however the dates on the eirin mark are blur. .it that normal? Or this poster maybe a fake? I have attached picture of the eirin mark for your reference.
(http://i59.tinypic.com/ws8txe.jpg)
i found another original copy of this poster online from a very reputable seller, that seller send me a photo of the eirin mark for the one he is selling and it has the same blurred numbers. i am kinda confused right now
Thank you for taking time out to read my msg, I appreciate any help given.
-
First, welcome1, yllum, to the forum. And enjoy.
Im sure some of the Japanese B1 poster collectors and experts will be happy to help with this.
Will you be posting a photo of the entire poster also? Would love to see the imagery.
Jeff
-
I think I got this poster from the same source as you did. However, when I received it, I was convinced that this poster is a reprint, mainly because of the Erin mark is so blurry as you found. In addition, I think these posters appeared in batch recently in the market, and the paper appeared not aging at all given more than 35 years. I have seen the B2 version of this poster of the same design, where the Erin mark is clear and sharp. I will let you know when I gather more information, but I am still convinced for now that it is a reprint.
-
welcome1, too, yllum.
And enjoy the poster pow wow, too. :D
-
I have one of these too... same deal -- correct size for a B1, sloppy-yet-sharp print in the credits, but the artwork is strangely blurry, and frankly it's available way too readily for too little cost to be genuine. I thought I might be getting a deal when I bought mine a year or so back, but I wrote it off 5 seconds after seeing it in person...
That all said, I know a few experts I can inquire with. I'll see what they come back with...
-
Yep, I have the same one too. It's far too poor quality to be genuine... hell, it's too poor quality to even be a decent bootleg. crying
-
Looks like several of us have been stung.
Who is the seller?
I think we should be warning others, eh?
-
Got mine out of Japan about a year ago... just checked and the seller is no longer active. Warning bells are a ringin'!
-
Since it seems everyone has been invited to this party, I wanna see what the full poster looks like!
-
This?**
(http://www.posteritati.com/jpglg/_/027499.JPG)
**from Posteritati's site. They have a B1 size and it is listed for $150.00
-
That's the one. This is the reply I got back from my collector friend:
B1 size poster are almost [all] reprint not original on this title.
You might be find original copy, but not many chances.
-
The Erin mark looks to be more bold/defined on the Posteritati copy. Could it be an original, maybe?
Here's their link (not promoting a sale).. it's just for those that want to quickly click & look:
http://www.posteritati.com/product_details.php?multi=yes&skuvalue=120301
-
Hello Everyone, thanks for all your suggestion and advices
the following is the photo taken of my poster
(http://i59.tinypic.com/21ngwb5.jpg)
Sorry I am not really good with photo taking :)
As you can see from the photo, the rest of the poster has sharp and well defined image. The size is right too. However the Eirin Mark is blurred
Does anyone here has the Original B1 of this movie? i would love to take a look and compare the differences?
This is my first foray into Japanese cinema poster, i must say it was quite an disappointment :( i try talking to the japanese seller on ebay but he is adamant that the poster is an original.
Fellow Collectors, what should i do with regards to this case? i don't think i could get any refund from the seller. In fact, i can't even confirm whether the poster is a fake or not.
To be honest, if this is a fake poster, i am rather surprised by why would there be one, especially at B1 size. This movie is not even popular as compared to the rest of Miyazaki's work. This is an underrated Miyazaki film, in fact alot of general audience doesn't even know that this is a miyazaki's movie. I can understand if there are fake for spirited away, laputa or Princess mononoke :)
-
That's the one. This is the reply I got back from my collector friend:
Does your friend has an original for comparison? Did he mention how do we tell an original from an fake?
Thank you!
-
The Erin mark looks to be more bold/defined on the Posteritati copy. Could it be an original, maybe?
Here's their link (not promoting a sale).. it's just for those that want to quickly click & look:
http://www.posteritati.com/product_details.php?multi=yes&skuvalue=120301
Thanks for the link.
After suspecting there might be something wrong with my poster, i actually went online to hunt for other copy a few days back
Lupin iii: castle of cagliostro is one of my favourite and i really wanted an original Japanese poster for it.
My search actually lead to Posteritati, with every intention of buying from them. i Know they are a very reputable dealer.
However, just to be on the safe side, i requested for an clear image of the Eirin Mark of the poster they are selling.
Guess what, the poster that they are selling as a Original B1 has the same exact blurred Eirin Mark as what i had.
So now i am really confused.
-
I think I got this poster from the same source as you did. However, when I received it, I was convinced that this poster is a reprint, mainly because of the Erin mark is so blurry as you found. In addition, I think these posters appeared in batch recently in the market, and the paper appeared not aging at all given more than 35 years. I have seen the B2 version of this poster of the same design, where the Erin mark is clear and sharp. I will let you know when I gather more information, but I am still convinced for now that it is a reprint.
Thank you, kindly let me know if you have more information
-
My friend has never owned one... and he has owned almost everything at one point or another. To me that says a lot. I imagine originals are extremely scarce -- for all the reasons you mentioned. As I said above, these rolled mint copies that have turned up lately are just too plentiful and too cheap.
I don't really have any advice for you, other than to welcome you to the collecting world! You're not a true collector until you've been burned at least once ;) Little comfort I'm sure -- and maybe too soon to joke! Sorry again. If you can't return it I would just keep for reference someday -- that is what I've done with mine. And as you say, we won't know for sure until a different copy turns up. I'll keep working on my sources in the mean time...
-
My friend has never owned one... and he has owned almost everything at one point or another. To me that says a lot. I imagine originals are extremely scarce -- for all the reasons you mentioned. As I said above, these rolled mint copies that have turned up lately are just too plentiful and too cheap.
I don't really have any advice for you, other than to welcome you to the collecting world! You're not a true collector until you've been burned at least once ;) Little comfort I'm sure -- and maybe too soon to joke! Sorry again. If you can't return it I would just keep for reference someday -- that is what I've done with mine. And as you say, we won't know for sure until a different copy turns up. I'll keep working on my sources in the mean time...
lol yeah. .I may be on my way to being a true collector :'( even though there is no confirmation that it is a fake. I remain skeptical
the saddest part is I didn't really get it too cheap. .I am $88 poorer. Haha
thanks for your time in looking out for answers. I appreciate it :)
I must say there are lot of friendly folks here in this forum, I feel very welcomed.
-
And with these being the exact right size and all, clear sharp printing (aside from the Erin mark).. would these be considered bootlegs? Or just later (legitimate) released reprints? dontknow.gif
-
lol yeah. .I may be on my way to being a true collector :'( even though there is no confirmation that it is a fake. I remain skeptical
the saddest part is I didn't really get it too cheap. .I am $88 poorer. Haha
I am a huge fan of that film & poster too. I hope you can consider that $88 as an investment towards your poster education. We all had one or two flops.
-
Thanks for the link.
After suspecting there might be something wrong with my poster, i actually went online to hunt for other copy a few days back
Lupin iii: castle of cagliostro is one of my favourite and i really wanted an original Japanese poster for it.
My search actually lead to Posteritati, with every intention of buying from them. i Know they are a very reputable dealer.
However, just to be on the safe side, i requested for an clear image of the Eirin Mark of the poster they are selling.
Guess what, the poster that they are selling as a Original B1 has the same exact blurred Eirin Mark as what i had.
So now i am really confused.
I emailed Sam at Posteritati and he said he had also checked with his Japanese experts who agreed that their copy is a later reprint. He also said he will be removing it from both the bay and their site (or maybe re-listing it with an updated or revised description).
He also commented that he thinks these copies are reprints and not bootlegs, that were meant to be sold, but will try and verify this, too, if he can. ;)
-
I emailed Sam at Posteritati and he said he had also checked with his Japanese experts who agreed that their copy is a later reprint. He also said he will be removing it from both the bay and their site (or maybe re-listing it with an updated or revised description).
He also commented that he thinks these copies are reprints and not bootlegs, that were meant to be sold, but will try and verify this, too, if he can. ;)
Oh Sam replied me too. With regards to the poster, Sam mentioned thar 2 of his Japanese expert believe there is a good chance that it is a reproduction. He has remove his from sale
-
And with these being the exact right size and all, clear sharp printing (aside from the Erin mark).. would these be considered bootlegs? Or just later (legitimate) released reprints? dontknow.gif
I would love to know the answer too. How does an original look like?
Any expert on this forum who has this particular B1 in your collection? Could you kindly share a photo please.
-
I got one or two of the reprints in a lot once. Was pretty obvious for all the reasons above that it could not be an original release. I have never seen in person one that looked different, nor have I seen one for sale that I suspected was the real deal.
-
I emailed Sam at Posteritati and he said he had also checked with his Japanese experts who agreed that their copy is a later reprint. He also said he will be removing it from both the bay and their site (or maybe re-listing it with an updated or revised description).
He also commented that he thinks these copies are reprints and not bootlegs, that were meant to be sold, but will try and verify this, too, if he can. ;)
They have had a history of having things like this stay on there website - they had a Sam Jackson Pulp Fiction 40x60 mockup listed as original for years. Glad that they are taking action with this.
-
I know this poster was discussed recently but I can't find the posts on it (including mine). Regardless, future discussion should probably go in this thread...
I think I may have solved the mystery of these blurry-eirin Cagliostro B1s. Quite a few of my trusted seller's in Japan have them and they all got them recently. That got me thinking they have a good chance at being legit -- yet they are always rolled and in very good condition.
Well, I recently came across a chirashi for a "digitally remastered" Cagliostro release on May 9th 2014.
(http://i1048.photobucket.com/albums/s369/drharrycaul/random%20pics/von_dutch080-img600x426-1436281540hlirv56132_zpswkrqvfox.jpg)
There was a blu-ray released in Japan for this title back in 2008, but apparently the quality wasn't very good. From what I can understand, it was remastered and re-released on blu-ray in May of 2014 and there was also a small theatrical re-release that coincided with the event. Given that these blurry-eirin B1s didn't start showing up until around the same time I'm guessing these must be from that release. Here is an article discussing the remastering and theatrical re-release. I don't ready Japanese, but you can get the gist from Google translate:
http://www.famitsu.com/news/201404/23052187.html
So maybe this is a legit, theatrical R2014 B1? Mystery solved?
-
The other original thread, with all comments posted, is alive and well, right here, Matt:
http://www.allposterforum.com/index.php/topic,9740.0.html
cheers
-
Any chance you could combine the threads? Seems like the discussion should belong in the authentication section... thanks!
-
Will be done.
-
Much obliged!
-
Any time! cheers
-
After 5+ years of searching I finally found a first release 1979 Japanese B1! I also own the R2014 poster so I made up an authentication post on my blog. Enjoy!
Authentication | Lupin III – The Castle of Cagliostro Japanese B1 1979 vs. R2014
(http://marqueeposter.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Authentication-lead-image-alternate.jpg) (http://marqueeposter.com/authentication-lupin-iii-the-castle-of-cagliostro-japanese-b1/)