I agree.
EMP is a great website, but is certainly overwhelming. There is a ton of information/pictures/banners/options/etc. on every page, and a lot of it is redundant and can be confusing - especially to new users. And I imagine even 'veteran' users have to "turn off" most of the supplemental stuff in order to focus on what they want. As a result, if you ever add updates or changes to policies, many will probably not even notice them.
Additionally, I think the fact that you have complex combined shipping rules (ie: Auction A can ship with B, D, E, G, H, and K Auctions, but not with C, F, I and J) can cause many people to get frustrated trying to figure it out, and simply default to hitting 0 (contacting a live person to explain it to them).
Don't get me wrong, I still think most people are idiots, but I also think that a few things on the website could be streamlined.